Returns process review: an online shoe store with slow refunds
Current flow: where the time goes
Step
Takes now
Problem
Customer asks for a return
2 days
No form: requests come by email and wait for a reply
Parcel travels back
6 days
—
Inspection in the warehouse
5 days
Returns are checked once a week, on Mondays
Refund paid
6 days
Finance approves refunds by hand, in batches
Total
19 days
Main findings
41% of returns are "too small". The size chart doesn't say that two of the brands run small.
23% of support tickets in October were "Where is my refund?"
Exchanges are handled as a return plus a new order, so the customer pays twice and waits twice.
Improvement plan
Self-service return form with a prepaid label (week 1)
"Runs small, order a half size up" note on the two brands' product pages (week 1)
Daily inspection; refunds under $150 paid automatically once the parcel is scanned (week 2)
One-step exchange: the new size ships as soon as the return is scanned (week 4)
Metrics to track
Metric
Now
Target in 3 months
Days to refund
19
7
"Where is my refund?" tickets
23%
under 8%
Return rate
14%
11%
Delivered
A process map, the 6-page report, and a one-page checklist for the warehouse team.
Client: Stride Lane, an online shoe store with 1,800 orders a month and a 14% return rate
Task: find out why refunds take 19 days on average and complaints keep growing, and propose fixes